Here are my remarks - Organization of the EGI into federation is not clear to me. GEANT is not managed as federation. - p. 10, The EGI vision does not include industry. I think it should be added. - p. 18, Why is middleware development is done within EGI which operational ? - p. 25,49 The SLA and resources that are shared should be at VO level and not at the NGI or EGI level.<- This is different than slide 8 of your presentation. - section 5.3.2.1 - I would suggest to use the term "cloud computing" rather than "ultimate application accelerator" as it specify that it is not related to a specific location. - EGI can not contradict the local law or licensing in terms of disclosure (e.g. for security incidents) and rights of usage.